Hey DM,

I just setup using POP and SMTP via Mac mail with Synchronet (its great that SBBS can do POP/SMTP email)...

I sent an email today, to: User One <xxxx@4ma.xyz>, with a cc: User Two <yyyy@bbs.nz> from mac mail.

When it sent I watched the logs and noticed this:

mail 0073 SMTP <deon> deon relaying to external mail service: 4ma.xyz
mail 0073 SMTP <deon> deon relaying to external mail service: bbs.nz
mail 0073 SMTP <deon> Receiving mail message from <xxxx@xxx.dege.au> to <xxxx@bbs.nz>
mail 0073 SMTP <deon> End of message (body: 563 lines, 30587 bytes, header: 13 lines, 590 bytes)
mail 0073 SMTP <deon> Added message header #5548 from 'Deon George' #1 to <xxxx@4ma.xyz>
mail 0073 SMTP <deon> Added message header #5549 from 'Deon George' #1 to <yyyy@bbs.nz>
mail 0000 SEND Message #5548 (374 of 375) from 'Deon George' #1 to 'User One' <xxxx@4ma.xyz>
mail 0086 SEND/TLS Successfully sent message #5548 (30589 bytes, 564 lines) from 'Deon George' #1 to 'User One' <xxxx@4ma.xyz>
mail 0000 SEND Message #5549 (375 of 375) from 'Deon George' #1 to 'User One' <yyyy@bbs.nz>
mail 0086 SEND/TLS Successfully sent message #5549 (30589 bytes, 564 lines) from 'Deon George' #1 to 'User One' <yyyy@bbs.nz>

Notice that the log records both outbound emails as "User One", instead of the email to @bbs.nz should be "User Two" (on the last line above).

So I logged on and looked at sent mails via the ;MAIL, and noticed something completely different:

The message was recorded twice (OK), the first one rendered correctly (the receipients named matched the email address), the second one was different:

┌────────────────────────····
│ Subj: Re: fsxnet application
│ Attr: Deleted Sent KillSent
│ To : User One (yyyy@bbs.nz)
│ CC : User Two <yyyy@bbs.nz>
│ From: Deon George #1 (xxxx@xxx.dege.au)
│ Date: Sat Feb 04 2023 09:50 pm UTC+11:00 (35 minutes ago)
└

The "To" has the correct name, but the wrong email address.

I checked my SMTP log, and it appears the mails were sent to the right people - not sure if their names were correct though...?

....δεσ∩

---
■ Synchronet ■ AnsiTEX bringing back videotex but with ANSI

Re: SMTP outbound mail from a mail client
By: deon to Digital Man on Sat Feb 04 2023 10:53 pm

> Hey DM,
>
> I just setup using POP and SMTP via Mac mail with Synchronet (its great that
> SBBS can do POP/SMTP email)...
>
> I sent an email today, to: User One <xxxx@4ma.xyz>, with a cc: User Two
> <yyyy@bbs.nz> from mac mail.
>
> When it sent I watched the logs and noticed this:
>
> mail 0073 SMTP <deon> deon relaying to external mail service: 4ma.xyz
> mail 0073 SMTP <deon> deon relaying to external mail service: bbs.nz
> mail 0073 SMTP <deon> Receiving mail message from <xxxx@xxx.dege.au> to
> <xxxx@bbs.nz>
> mail 0073 SMTP <deon> End of message (body: 563 lines, 30587 bytes, header:
> 13 lines, 590 bytes)
> mail 0073 SMTP <deon> Added message header #5548 from 'Deon George' #1 to
> <xxxx@4ma.xyz>
> mail 0073 SMTP <deon> Added message header #5549 from 'Deon George' #1 to
> <yyyy@bbs.nz>
> mail 0000 SEND Message #5548 (374 of 375) from 'Deon George' #1 to 'User
> One' <xxxx@4ma.xyz>
> mail 0086 SEND/TLS Successfully sent message #5548 (30589 bytes, 564 lines)
> from 'Deon George' #1 to 'User One' <xxxx@4ma.xyz>
> mail 0000 SEND Message #5549 (375 of 375) from 'Deon George' #1 to 'User
> One' <yyyy@bbs.nz>
> mail 0086 SEND/TLS Successfully sent message #5549 (30589 bytes, 564 lines)
> from 'Deon George' #1 to 'User One' <yyyy@bbs.nz>
>
> Notice that the log records both outbound emails as "User One", instead of
> the email to @bbs.nz should be "User Two" (on the last line above).

Yeah, the log messages for multiple recipients of a single message are a bit wonky. That's a known issue, but not a particularly high priority to "fix".

> So I logged on and looked at sent mails via the ;MAIL, and noticed something
> completely different:
>
> The message was recorded twice (OK), the first one rendered correctly (the
> receipients named matched the email address), the second one was different:
>
> ┌────────────────────────····
> │ Subj: Re: fsxnet application
> │ Attr: Deleted Sent KillSent
> │ To : User One (yyyy@bbs.nz)
> │ CC : User Two <yyyy@bbs.nz>
> │ From: Deon George #1 (xxxx@xxx.dege.au)
> │ Date: Sat Feb 04 2023 09:50 pm UTC+11:00 (35 minutes ago)
> └
>
> The "To" has the correct name, but the wrong email address.
>
> I checked my SMTP log, and it appears the mails were sent to the right
> people - not sure if their names were correct though...?

If you enable debug level log output and the DEBUG_TX option in the [mail]
section of ctrl/sbbs.ini, you'll get to see all the message headers as they were sent.
--
digital man (rob)

This Is Spinal Tap quote #11:
Nigel Tufnel: No. no. That's it, you've seen enough of that one.
Norco, CA WX: 68.9°F, 34.0% humidity, 10 mph SSE wind, 0.00 inches rain/24hrs
---
■ Synchronet ■ Vertrauen ■ Home of Synchronet ■ [vert/cvs/bbs].synchro.net

wow great
---
� Synchronet � Zruspa's BBS